you know what they say…
i’ve had something on my mind for a while now, and i thought i’d share it with you. you are really lucky. you feel lucky, don’t you?
okay, here goes. i’ve been wondering whether or not it REALLY matters if you stir a kitchen concoction in one direction only as some recipes instruct. (clue #3429 that i have a lot of time on my hands AND clearly have no life.)
before turning to the internets, i thought i’d test the theory in my own kitchen. over the weekend i made 24 quarts of oregon hood strawberry jam…which means i was standing, sweaty and stirring for the majority of saturday. as i was stirring my 4th batch of jam, the whole ‘stir in one direction’ thing popped into my head.
slow-cooked jam making involves a lot of stirring - basically you want the fruit & sugar to boil without burning, so you want the heat to be gentle and you want to take your time arriving at the boil - which means stirring, stirring and more stirring. and the only way to make sure your jam has boiled enough is to wait until it is hot enough to boil so that stirring doesn’t make the boil go away.
here’s what i did to test the theory:
- just as the jam was about to reach the type of boil that wouldn’t go away with stirring, i stirred in the other direction a few strokes, then the original direction a few strokes.
- each time i did this, i noticed the jam would quickly reduce its bubbly/boiling action. it would take half a minute or so to come up to the boil again.
BUT, if i stirred in the SAME direction as the jam was about to reach the ‘big’ boil, it would:
- continue on its path to the type of boil that couldn’t be stirred away.
to further test the theory, i then waited for the type of boil that couldn’t be stirred away to be in full swing and i:
- stirred in one direction then quickly changed directions only to watch the boil wane a bit!
what do these tests prove? that stirring in one direction only simply stirs the pot, while continuously changing direction not only stirs but also incorporates more air - which can cool down your concoction enough to effect a rapid boil. incredible! and so scientific, right? yes, right.
just call me dr. sprinklefingers.
ps: when i finally did turn to the internet to prove my theory, there was a lot of talk about custards, dumplings & mayos, etc. and stirring in one direction. to be perfectly honest with you, i had already tested the theory for myself where temperature was concerned and didn’t really have the desire to wade through so & so’s crummy blog to find out what multi-directional stirring does (or doesn’t do, more likely) to custards.

